Hey Man, That’s Not Yours!

27 02 2014

f56392d4841f119aa49c9928a7883bc61cb8eefad4542341996522b7379f4f3aI recently overheard some discussion among civil war researchers who present their work in public through speaking and writing on the web. They voice concern regarding “lifting” of their work by readers and attendees. Some cite examples of their work being presented by others in public and print as their own – without attribution. I’ve written before that it’s a risk we all take, and should even expect it to happen. But I have to admit to being a little concerned in this regard about my upcoming talk – assuming anyone else would consider my notion more than harebrained.

Of course the whole idea of Bull Runnings is sharing things. Recently someone mentioned to me that I have all these great letters that no one else has, to which I replied “Well, really, they all have them too.” But now we’re talking ideas and interpretation, not just photos and documents. It feels different.

What are your thoughts? Any examples of which you can think? Has it happened to you? How has it affected your sharing? Here’s your chance to vent…



2 responses

27 02 2014
Susan Evelyn McDowell Cole

I quit worrying about this a long time ago. Frequently when my ideas are stolen the implementation of that stolen idea is so poorly done that I just laugh atit.


27 02 2014
Dale Fishel

And then…there’s the distortion of sources to cherry pick the assumptions that a speaker/author chooses to make. Omissions of facts contrary to the speaker/authors theories are also “convenient” for some folks. That’s even more difficult to deal with as few of us actually check sources. Being the trusting folks we are we assume the speaker/author is honest and endeavoring to tell the truth…sadly, that isn’t always the case.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: