Thanks for the Thanks

17 08 2010

Today I received a nicely inscribed hardcover copy of War Like The Thunderbolt from its author, Russell Bonds.  This replaces the advance reading copy (ARC)/uncorrected proof/bound galley I was provided for review (read that review here).  Russ also included a handwritten Thank You note on a cool card with an embossed image of The General, the subject of Mr. Bonds’s preceding work.

As you can see, my review while generally positive was not free of criticism.  And lots of folks with much bigger wigs than mine reviewed Russ’s book, and some in more glowing terms.  This is the first time any author has gone to such lengths to thank me for a review (though most are generally gracious).  Bloggers who review books – as far as I know – don’t usually receive any compensation for doing so outside of the book itself.  ARCs are first very, very difficult to review (they typically have no indexes or maps and very poor quality images if any) and second they are, well, worthless – we don’t like to put them on our shelves.  So Russ’s gift was very thoughtful and fortunate, as this very successful book has gone into paperback and hardcovers are tough to come by.  And don’t get me started on publishers who offer to provide pdf copies of the book.  Double yoi!

Still, sometimes folks want to get the word out before the product is finished.  Such was the case with Thunderbolt.  Authors and publishers take note – this is the way to do things.  Thanks, Russ – you’re one classy guy!



4 responses

17 08 2010
Jim Miller

I could not agree with you more, Harry. When I reviewed “War Like The Thunderbolt” I got a very nice note from Mr. Bonds, and I was very happy with that!


17 08 2010
Steve Basic


Does not surprise me at all. During my time as VP of Programs I was fortunate to have Russell as one of my speakers. His talk on his first book still resonates with our members here, as the speakers here tend to focus on the war in the Eastern Theater. Russell spent quite some time signing books after his talk, and was great to work with.

Hope all is well.



18 08 2010
Robert Redd

I had the honor of meeting Russell and his lovely wife at a talk he gave in St. Augustine. Class act all around. He met me at the door and welcomed me. He made my wife and I feel right at home at an SCV group where we knew nobody. I really enjoyed both his books and am looking forward to whatever he tackles next!


18 08 2010
S. Thomas Summers

Related link. Featured on The Atlantic’s web site a few days ago.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: