Civil War History – Broadening Horizons?

31 08 2007


cwh1.jpgYesterday I received in the mail my copy of Volume 53, Number 3 of Civil War History.  I’ve been a subscriber for the last seven or eight years.  Over that time, the journal’s focus has shifted considerably away from military history, and now features essays primarily on race and gender issues, mirroring a similar trend in the academy.  In fact, over the past five years I think I can count the number of military history essays that have appeared in its pages on one hand and have a few fingers left over.  But I’ve continued to subscribe, even though the current focus is not what I “signed on for”, because I like the book reviews and because I realize these things are cyclical, and pendulums tend to swing like England do.  Even so, I’ve been considering letting my subscription expire without renewal.

Imagine my surprise upon receiving this issue which features not one, not two, but three essays on military history – specifically, battle history.  The collection is edited by Frank Wetta, and consists of Ken Noe’s Jigsaw Puzzles, Mosaics, and Civil War Battle Narratives; George Rable’s The Battlefield and Beyond; and Carol Reardon’s Writing Battle History: The Challenge of Memory.  Could it be that CWH is putting the War back in Civil War?

The essays of Noe and Reardon address issues discussed here in the past.  Noe writes on the problems of the narrative form, among other things, and Reardon looks at (and defines) memory and its sometimes detrimental effects on history.  Rable’s essay is interesting to me primarily because he uses First Bull Run as a backdrop for his discussion of the role of religion on the battlefield.

I’ll post separate articles on each essay in the days ahead, so check back if I’ve piqued your interest.



5 responses

5 09 2007
The Business of Civil War « Bull Runnings

[…] try to post my thoughts on the Ken Noe essay in Civil War History that I talked about in my last post.  Dmitri mentioned it here, and it seems the topic of the problems with the narrative form in the […]


19 09 2007
Coming Up « Bull Runnings

[…] been thinking a lot about the Ken Noe essay in Civil War History I discussed here.  I think I’ve kinda sorta figured out what I want to say.  This has caused much consternation, […]


9 05 2008
Latest Issue of Civil War History (March 2008) Looks Promising

[…] having reservations similar to Harry Smeltzer’s, I finally decided to resubscribe to Civil War History, a journal published by The Kent State […]


16 11 2008
History as Narrative « Bull Runnings

[…] ever since I read the essays on military history in the most recent issue of Civil War History (see here), but the trouble in my noggin has been brewing for a long time.  In a Carlos Castaneda magic […]


5 01 2011
North & South Magazine January 2011 « Bull Runnings

[…] Almost Chosen Peoples: A Religious History of the American Civil War.  And a long while back, I implied I would look into an essay of Rable’s in Civil War History in which he “uses First […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: