Lest We Forget

22 08 2007

lest-we.jpgI love reference works.  I have a shelf right over my desk on which I place facts-at-my-fingertips type books like Generals in Blue, Generals in Gray, Dyer’s Compendium, Fox’s Regimental Losses, Lincoln Day-by-Day, you get the picture.  Today I received from Amazon Lest We Forget: The Grave Sites of the Union Civil War Generals Buried in the United States, by David L. Callihan.  This is a large format 2007 paperback similar in layout to Generals at Rest: The Grave Sites of the 425 Official Confederate Generals, by James Owen and Richard Owen.  It’s very handy, and includes the US burial sites of the same generals listed in Ezra Warner’s standard.  The entries are by state, with alphabetical arrangement first by city, then by cemetery.  For each general, the author notes birth and death places and dates, pre-war career, general officer date of rank, and helpful directions for finding the cemetery and the grave.  Included also is a portrait of each general and one to three photos of the grave.  Also included at the head of each of the 37 chapters is a state map (and one for DC) showing where the various towns with dead generals are located realtive to one another.

The only real knock I have is the quality of the photos.  By and large they’re pretty grainy, again similar to those found in Warner’s books.  In this day and age I think it would have been pretty easy to find and include higher quality images.  Of course that would have entailed more expense, and the book’s price may have wound up higher than the still high (for a paperback) $33.49 tag.  But then, these books will probably wind up in the back seats of their buyers’ cars while on family outings and vacations.  Good news for us, but I’m not sure our spouses and kids will be so happy.

About these ads



5 responses

28 08 2007
John Hoptak

Hey Harry~
Any mention or photograph in the book of General James Nagle and his final resting place? I know it’s a long-shot, but I thought I’d ask anyway.
BTW. . .I’ll be doing a lot of posts this week on the 48th PA at the battle of 2nd Bull Run. Not your main focus, I understand, but thought you’d be interested nonetheless. . .

28 08 2007
Harry Smeltzer


Page 473 shows two photos of the marker for Nagle in Pottsville’s Presbyterian Cemetery. You ever been there? ;-)

BTW, I’m planning to be in Sharpsburg for the Heritage Festival on the 15th. Hope to run into you at some point during the weekend.


29 08 2007
John Hoptak

Wow. . .I can’t believe Nagle made the list. I wonder if the photos are of the historical markers I had placed there back in 2004? Guess I’ll have to pick up a copy of Lest We Forget. . .

29 08 2007
Harry Smeltzer


No, the photos are of his tombstone, one portrait of the whole thing and a landscape shot of the text. According to the intro, the book includes everybody in Warner’s book (Generals in Blue), as long as they were buried in the US.


3 12 2007
Oh Fudge « Bull Runnings

[…] The Gravesites of Union Civil War Generals Buried in the United States (I wrote about the book here) I would have found in the Delaware section, on page 35, that Thomas Alfred Smyth is buried there, […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,154 other followers

%d bloggers like this: