More on the “New” Wheat Photo

20 10 2008

 

Here’s an update to this post about the “new” ambrotype of Rob Wheat.  The owner of the photo and author of the CWT article, Mike Musick, left the following comment:

Thanks for your interest in the picture, and observations. Love that shot from Seinfeld. The “new” photo, as it appears in the article and blog post, is in reverse. When it’s “flipped,” the similarities in appearance to the known portraits is somewhat increased.

I exchanged a few emails with Mr. Musick and learned that quite a few folks whose names you’d recognize agree to varying degrees that the fellow in the photo is Wheat.  In the interests of full disclosure, a couple names you’d also know aren’t so sure.  The original photo, which is not reversed and does not have a frame, was sent to me last December by a mutual friend, and I’ve been sitting on it since then.  Mr. Musick has graciously granted permission to show it here.

About these ads

Actions

Information

5 responses

21 10 2008
Kevin Coy

Harry,

Can you put the photos together again? When examining photos the ears are going to be the truth-teller. Ears are like fingerprints. Are the lobes the same, i.e. connected, separated, etc. ? Does the lower part of the ear align to the same place with the nose/mouth on both photos (draw a line across the face). How about the eye alignment to the ears? And the eyebrows?

21 10 2008
Harry Smeltzer

Kevin,

For some reason, I’m having trouble doing that just now. I think that, unless Wheat’s face is asymmetrical, you should be able to do what you suggest with the side by side photos in the previouos post.

I should add that some very prominent individuals who are very familiar with these types of ID techniques have come down on the “This may be Wheat” side of the question.

22 10 2008
A “New” Photo of Rob Wheat « Bull Runnings

[...] See foloow up post here. [...]

24 11 2008
Wheat Photo « Bull Runnings

[...] an individual who looks a lot like Rob Wheat of the 1st Special Louisiana Battalion (see here and here).  It included quite a few testimonials from big shots in the ACW field as to their opinions on [...]

27 02 2009
Wheat’s Report « Bull Runnings

[...] more on the Wheat ambrotype recently “discovered” by Mike Musick and discussed here and here.  Mike sent me a big packet of info, which I mentioned here.  I haven’t forgotten – I just [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 849 other followers

%d bloggers like this: