I don’t think anyone can say with certainty who “captured” Ricketts’s guns (I assume were talking about Ricketts, right?). They changed hands several times, and no regimental reports for Jackson’s brigade are in the ORs. 33rd VA, 27th VA, Billy Smith’s Battalion, 11 NY, 14th B’klyn, lots of back and forth. then there’s the question of which guns? Ricketts’s or Griffin’s? Most Rebel accounst just refer to “guns”. I admit to being thoroughly confused (to qoute the Dude onse more, “Lotta ins, lotta outs, lotta what-have-yous), and am leery of narratives that make the fighting on Henry House Hill sinsibly linear. I know that sounds like a cop out, but I like Detzer’s description of the fighting there best of all, efen if he doesn’t have any maps.

But to answer your question, no, I am not aware of any reports giveing credit for the final capture of Ricketts’s or Griffin’s guns.

As for which regiment, misidentified by Barry as friends, fired on Griffin’s guns, the jury is out. Some say the 33rd (MacDonald), some say Extra Billy Smith (Hennessy, though he claims that the 33rd did the capturing, after dispersing the the 11th NY and 1st MN), and Rafuse thinks a combination of the two. Detzer is I think right that “(t)he truth about what happened is likely to remain a riddle.” Unless we turn stuff up.

At UNC I found a spoeech written for the dedication of a portrait of Colonel Fisher of the 6th NC, in which the orator describes how the 6th NC saved the day by capturing the Union guns on Henry Hill. Lots of folks making claims.

If you have a document you’d like to share, I’m all (virtual) ears!!!